Free insured shipping on US orders · Every book authenticity-guaranteed
Creepy
#2 · 1965
Full multi-angle photography of this exact copy is sent before dispatch and is available on request.
Warren Publishing · 1965 · CGC 8.5 · Universal Blue
Creepy #2 (Warren Publishing, 1965) — Frank Frazetta Cover. CGC 8.5 Very Fine+.
In stock — 1 available·Free insured shipping·Ships in 2 business days
Secure checkout · Card, PayPal and bank wire accepted · Need to track an existing order? Track it here.
Authenticity guaranteed
Cert-verified against the grader's census. Undisclosed restoration refunded in full, forever.
Insured & tracked
Double-boxed, signature required, insured to full value.
14-day inspection
Return in the original holder within 14 days of delivery for a full refund.
Creepy #2, published by Warren Publishing in 1965 (Silver Age). Listing notes: Frank Frazetta Cover.
Graded CGC 8.5 Very Fine+. Certification number 4509593013, which can be checked on the CGC website. The book is sealed in its tamper-evident CGC holder.
This copy is encapsulated by CGC at 8.5 on a Universal Blue label under certification number 4509593013, which you can verify independently on the CGC website before you buy. The holder is intact and has not been cracked, re-sealed or altered.
Want to grade a book of your own? Our submission service covers pre-screening, tier selection and insured round-trip shipping at dealer rates, and professional pressing often adds a full grade point before the book is ever submitted.
No reviews yet. Verified buyers can review this listing from their order page after delivery.
Ask for additional photos, request a video walkaround of the slab, or book an in-person inspection at our Austin vault before you commit.
Background on Creepy, the grade and what drives the price.
Values
A comic book values price guide gives a reference figure for a title, issue and grade, but it is not what a particular copy will sell for. The real value comes from the exact condition of your copy and what comparable copies have recently sold for.
Updated Oct 11, 2026
Key issues
Wonder Woman was created by William Moulton Marston and artist H. G. Peter and first appeared in All Star Comics #8, published by DC Comics with a cover date of December 1941 – January 1942. That issue is the original Wonder Woman comic that collectors mean by her first appearance.
Updated Oct 11, 2026
CGC / CBCS
The value of CGC graded comics is set by the numeric grade, the page quality noted on the label, the label type (including any restoration), and demand for that specific issue. The only reliable figure is what the same issue in the same grade recently sold for.
Updated Oct 11, 2026
Grading
The comic grading scale used by CGC and CBCS runs from 0.5 to 10.0, with higher numbers meaning fewer defects. Graders judge the whole book, including spine, corners, page quality and restoration, and because collectors pay for condition, a small change in grade can change the price noticeably.
Updated Oct 11, 2026
Showcase
#4 · 1956
Fantastic Four
#1 · 1961
Amazing Fantasy
#15 · 1962
Incredible Hulk
#1 · 1962